Over the years, I've often been skeptical of many modern
evolutionary explanations. People usually assume it's because I'm religious.
That's only part of the story.
Originally, my opposition to evolution was purely
religious. The Bible said God created the world and the life within it, so that
settled the matter as far as I was concerned. I purchased a book on Scientific
Creationism, felt pretty confident in my position, and in the early 1990s began
frequenting atheist and evolutionist chat rooms. Armed with what I thought was
solid knowledge, I expressed that confidence freely, only to have my hat handed
to me by people who knew far more science than I did and came equipped with
papers and research that seemed to demonstrate the undeniability of
evolutionary theory.
As I read those papers, hoping to find flaws, I was struck
by the sheer volume of information I was up against. At first, the experience
was discouraging. I openly wondered whether my faith was even valid. Rather
than walk away, however, I decided to dig deeper. The more interested I became
in science, the more I discovered that the research was rarely as conclusive as
it was sometimes portrayed in popular discussions. Good scientists don't
permanently close doors. They follow evidence and remain willing to revise
conclusions when new evidence appears.
Then two important things happened. In 1996, I was offered
an apprenticeship as a manufacturing plant electrician. About a decade later, I
encountered Thomas Aquinas and his arguments for God's existence, including
what is known as the Fifth Way.
As an electrician, I learned the art of troubleshooting
industrial machinery. Day after day, I diagnosed failures by tracing wiring
diagrams, learning relay logic, PLC logic, and CNC logic, and trying to
understand how complex electrical, pneumatic, hydraulic, mechanical and
electronic systems worked individually and how they fit together. That
experience fundamentally changed the way I look at the world.
One thing you learn very quickly as a maintenance
electrician is that complex systems are almost never as simple as they appear.
The wire that seems unnecessary usually isn't. The logic you don’t fully
understand often performs a critical function. What looks straightforward on
the surface frequently turns out to be governed by layers of hidden logic,
feedback loops, contingencies, and safeguards. The deeper you investigate, the
more organization you discover.
Because of that background, something about many biological
explanations always struck me as odd. Researchers would identify some component
of life and conclude that it was probably a leftover, a historical relic, a
meaningless byproduct, or an accident of history. To me, that never sounded
quite right. My instinct was exactly the opposite. If living systems are
designed, then deeper investigation should reveal deeper purpose.
That mindset led me to make a number of predictions on
various discussion sites around 2007. I predicted that so-called "junk
DNA" would eventually be found to perform important functions. I predicted
that genetic systems would prove far more sophisticated than scientists then
realized. I expected hidden regulatory networks to be discovered, and I
anticipated that biological information would turn out to be layered,
overlapping, and densely packed.
I wasn't making those predictions because I had extensive
biological expertise. I was making them because I spent my days working with
complex engineered systems. Looking back, many of those expectations have aged
surprisingly well. The more researchers probe the cell, the more layers of
information they seem to find. The more carefully genomes are studied, the more
functionality appears in regions once considered insignificant. The more we
learn, the more life resembles an integrated information-processing system.
None of that proves God. No single scientific discovery ever
will. But it does raise an interesting question: Why does nature continue to
reveal deeper layers of organization?
This is where Aquinas' Fifth Way became important to me.
Until I discovered the Fifth Way, I had been using the standard Intelligent
Design 'Watchmaker' argument: that a complex system requires an intelligent
designer. But the Fifth Way is not an argument from complexity. It isn't the
claim that because things are complicated, they must have been assembled by a
divine mechanic. Aquinas' logic does not depend on the system being
complicated. His logic is about why the system is ordered at all.
Aquinas compared nature to an arrow shot at a target. The
arrow doesn't have the capacity to guide itself toward the target; it must be
directed by something with the capacity to aim it. He argued that the regular,
goal-directed behavior we observe throughout nature points beyond the
constituent things themselves. This applies to all levels of nature, not just
the complex ones.
The Fifth Way is, at its core, an argument about the
outcomes of organization. Why do unintelligent things consistently behave in
ways that produce organized outcomes? Hydrogen and oxygen reliably combine to
form water. Water reliably flows, evaporates, condenses, and flows again.
Across nature, matter behaves according to patterns that generate stable
systems, often revealing layers of sophisticated organization. Does nature
possess this organizing power entirely within itself? Or does the order we observe
point to something with the capacity, and the vision, to organize it?
As an electrician, when I see components consistently interacting to produce predictable outcomes, I infer that the system possesses an underlying logic or reason for that.
Modern science generally operates under the methodological
assumption that natural processes are sufficient to explain these natural
phenomena. Given enough time, stars form, planets form, life emerges, and
eventually conscious beings appear to wonder about their own existence.
Increasingly, however, I've found myself wondering whether that assumption
sometimes plays a role similar to the geocentric model in earlier centuries.
When scientists working within the geocentric system
encountered conflicting observations, additional layers of explanation were
introduced to preserve the underlying premise. Today, I often see something
similar happening within the broader evolutionary narrative. Ancient galaxies
appear earlier than expected. Complex life appears earlier than expected.
Genetic systems prove more sophisticated than expected. New layers of
regulation and function continue to emerge. Each surprise is ultimately
incorporated into the existing framework.
Maybe that's exactly what science should do. Or maybe, one
day, we'll discover that the underlying premise itself requires
reconsideration.
I don't claim to have all the answers, and I certainly don't view science as the enemy. In fact, I love science. To me, science is simply the process of discovering how creation works. What fascinates me is that the more science advances, the less accidental the universe appears.
The more I learn, the more it reminds me of something
familiar: a machine. Not a machine in the cold, mechanical sense, but a machine
filled with layers of information, coordination, purpose, and logic that reveal
themselves only through careful investigation.
After decades spent tracing logic and diagnosing systems,
I've developed certain expectations about what design looks like. When I
examine nature, I find those expectations confirmed far more often than
challenged.
That's why I keep expecting science to find more design.
And so far, it keeps giving me more reasons to do exactly
that.




